Rubric

Keep in mind that 10 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Urban Tree Assessment & Maintenance Plan
Urban Tree Assessment & Maintenance Plan
Criteria Ratings Pts
Presentation
The report is clearly presented with pages, subheadings, sections and images identified and organized.
All relevant data pertaining to the site (photographs, dimensions, environmental conditions, vocation) and the tree(s) (species, size, condition, location) should be clearly indicated.
Minimum word count of 2000 words
Maximum word count of 3000 words (not including bibliography/literature cited page)
threshold: pts
pts
10 pts
--
Brief
The overall aim and supporting objectives/deliverables of the selected mandate should be stated at the beginning of the report. Any contextual or background information justifying the necessity for this mandate should be explained (site history, client expectations, regulatory compliance, safety considerations or conflicts to resolve). The limits of the report should also be stated (timeframe, location, competencies of the author, potential requirement for follow ups).
threshold: pts
pts
10 pts
--
Observations
In this section, all visual observations, data collected, measurements and photographs should be presented. Valuable and pertinent information about the site (vocation/land use, constraints, conflicts, utilities, infrastructure, targets, climate conditions, grade, surface treatment) as well as the tree(s) (species, size, condition, location) should be explained here.

It is also important to mention when any data was collected from the site and when photographs were taken. Document site visits relating to any information included in your observations.
threshold: pts
pts
30 pts
--
Discussion
This section should cover any industry-recognized methodologies used when interpreting the data collected and visual assessments performed.
All relevant complications should be identified and discussed. Possible resolutions and strategies should be presented with clear recommendations. Approximate timeframes for implementation of all interventions recommended must be specified. This can be in a matter of specified days, weeks, months or years depending on the scope and urgency of the intervention.

Discussion and assertions supported with credible relevant research and/or industry standards. These resources must be appropriately cited and included in a bibliography at the end of the report.
threshold: pts
pts
30 pts
--
Conclusion
This section should summarize the findings of the inspection and analysis followed by a resumé of the interventions recommended along with next possible steps for follow ups or interventions from other professionals, if needed.
Risks for the project are acknowledged and the resources required are specified.
threshold: pts
pts
10 pts
--
Referencing
Adequate knowledge of previous relevant research literature and applicable industry standards is demonstrated. A bibliography of references consulted and cited must be included in APA 7th edition formatting, without errors.
threshold: pts
pts
10 pts
--